Hymns and Atonement Theory

26 06 2011

I have recently attended two ordinations where a famous Christian hymn was sung. It’s lyrics were changed at one so as not to offend an intolerant group of liberal agitators in our denomination, at the other I was told that a few of the congregation chose not to sing the line (I did not notice their silence personally). Quite apart from the fact that, out of respect for others, I sing plenty of liberal tripe without grumbling and display none of their angst about this, I wonder how they square their intolerance for the lyric of this hymn with the recognition of the United Reformed Church’s own particular heritage of faith in statements of Congregationalists, Presbyterians and Churches of Christ.

In particular the language of this hymn can be drawn completely from the Westminster Confession and the Savoy Declaration where the ‘wrath of God’ against unredeemed humanity is affirmed (WC: chapter VI paragraph VI, SD: chapter 6 paragraph 6) and where Christ’s work upon the cross is seen as ‘undertaking the punishment due to us’ (SD: chapter 8 paragraph 4) and ‘satisfying the Father’s justice on our behalf’ (WC: chapter XI paragraph III and SD: chapter 11 paragraph 3). Ironically, whilst we state in the ordination service that we acknowledge these declarations in the statement concerning the nature faith and order, it appears that we may not recognise these declarations when they confront us in our hymnary!




3 responses

4 08 2011

So now I wonder what the hymn was, and what the line was.

As a one-time liberal agitator myself I once made two lists: one of boss-nation hymns, and the other of oppressed and downtrodden people’s hymns. I preferredf the latter.

4 08 2011

It is the promise of a just court, a higher King, and a glorious redemption that warms the hearts of the downtrodden and strikes fear into the hearts of the oppressor – we need faith in our Soveriegn God!

10 08 2012

That sounds horribly liberal to me!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: